Tribeca's Hallelujah Chorus

Text and Photos by Carl Glassman

Each Sunday morning, congregants file to their seats in the spare, newly converted sanctuary at Greenwich and Vestry Streets, accompanied by the infectious rhythms of a three-piece band and a gospel chorus. By the time soloist Carolyn Miller has belted out her second or third rock-influenced spiritual of the morning, the polished, electrifying force of the music is sending bodies swaying, arms lifting, and 200 voices ringing in song.

Into the sleepy Sunday stillness of northern Tribeca, old-time religion has arrived.

During a healing session at a Sunday service last month, Pastor Ann Stratton lays hands on Bernard Shepherd, who has diabetes. Clarence Fisher stands ready to catch Shepherd if he collapses.

The evangelical Christian congregation, called Faith Exchange Fellowship, moved into the 15,000- square-foot space of the commercial building in May, after more than three years of searching for a Downtown landlord who would rent or sell them a ground-floor property. That search began after the congregation's upstairs home at 90 West Street, across the street from the World Trade Center, was destroyed on Sept. 11.


Pastor Dan Stratton, who leads the congregation with his wife, Ann, said he was turned down by owners of 80 buildings.

"They said, 'We don't want a church on the ground floor, it sets the wrong tone for the building,'" recalled Stratton, 46, a former Yale football player whose hefty, 6-foot 2-inch frame and booming preacher's voice seem a good fit for this sprawling, ground-floor sanctuary.


Stratton is well aware that Tribeca is alien territory for his fundamentalist congregation. "Lower Manhattan has done a pretty good job of shutting Jesus out," he said. But he insists that he wants his church to fit in.

"I think we'll be surprised by who will end up coming here as we become part of the community."

Backed by a three-piece band and chorus, Carolyn Miller leads off Sunday services with rousing gospel singing.
Anne Ibrahimi, left, and Andrea Bonifacio dance at a Faith Exchange service. "It's like a great party every Sunday," said Bonifacio.
Evangelical congregations are hardly new to the area. Living Word Community Church, under Pastor Tommy Nichols, has long been in the neighborhood and meets at the Knitting Factory. Mosaic Manhattan, led by Gregg Ferrah, holds well-attended services at P.S./I.S. 89. But Faith Exchange, with its own space and a rent of $40,000 a month, according to Stratton, is now the most visible.

Stratton made the church all the more eye-catching by putting up a green awning that wraps around the corner of the building. (The sign went up without the Landmarks Preservation Commission's approval, according to the agency's spokeswoman, Diane Jackier.)

"Our neighbors love us, we are an asset to this community, and they know it. Amen, " he told his congregation one Sunday last month.

While that pronouncement may sound like prayerful positive thinking, Stratton does get high praise from second-floor neighbors Elizabeth Rossi and Sadie Nardini, proprietors of Shri Yoga, who had worried that the jubilant music and singing would shatter the peace in their studio.

"We weren't sure what to expect, but he was instantly more than accommodating," said Nardini, who lauded Stratton for reordering the music portion of the service to avoid a disruption of classes. "Actually [the church] is kind of a bonus," she added. "It sounds like life downstairs. I like that."

A band practice at 8:30 one Sunday morning provoked a swift complaint from a neighbor across the street, Steve Boyce, and a vow from Pastor Dan that it would not happen again. While the early playing stopped, Boyce said the church's open windows still allow more hallelujahs, handclapping and preaching into his apartment than he cares to hear. "They've said they'd be putting in air conditioning, but that hasn't happened yet," Boyce said. "So we all feel like we're participating in the services here."

"My goal is to get to know you, and be a blessing to you," Stratton said of his neighbors. "And it's kind of weird because now, for the first time, I'm really in a neighborhood."

A woman lies prone after Stratton has prayed for her. "The power of God is so heavy sometimes you cannot stand up," said Pastor Ann. "It is a wonderful, powerful feeling." The pastor periodically holds special healing services at the church.
Indeed, the church had been a neighbor to no one since its unlikely beginning more than 20 years ago on the floor of the Mercantile Exchange in 4 World Trade Center.

Dan Stratton preaches at a Sunday service.

Stratton, a former commodities trader who turned to full-time pastoring six years ago, said he had no preaching ambitions back in 1984 when he began reading his bible during lulls in trading.

"The guys would say, 'What, are you nuts, man? You're out of your mind.' They were really busting my chops."


To keep them quiet, Stratton placed a box by his phones and said he would respond to comments if they were written down and dropped in the box. He called it the "Faith Exchange." When the questions and comments grew numerous, he put the messages in a newsletter placed under the box.

The circulation of Stratton's newsletters grew to 1,500 by 1991, when a colleague began handing them out in other exchanges in the building. Stratton, trading crude oil at the time, was becoming known as the man to turn to for bible talk. He began holding bible study classes in his office at the end of the trading day. When attendance outgrew the space, he rented a room across the street at

90 West Street, then took on more and more space in the building as his following expanded.

Ever since the World Trade Center collapse sent flames shooting through 90 West Street, Stratton's congregation has been meeting in hotels and looking for a permanent home. Ann Stratton said she was so happy when she met the landlord of their new Greenwich Street space that she cried. "God called us to this neighborhood," she said.

Members of the multiracial, economically diverse congregation travel from around the city to the church's Sunday morning and Thursday evening services. Some come to ask Pastor Dan to pray for deliverance from illnesses, financial worries, marital problems and a host of other troubles, big and small.

Daraka Brown reflects in silent prayer.
The congregation at Faith Exchange Fellowship.
At one Thursday service last month, Stratton handed a formerly homeless woman $100, prayed for a woman whose husband was in prison, and for another whose father was desperately ill. A man dressed in a security guard's uniform raised his hand as Stratton preached. The pastor placed his hand on the man's shoulder as the guard quietly confided that two days before, on the brink of suicide, he had given up his gun. The guard had been working in the World Trade Center on Sept. 11 and had not yet rid himself of demons from that day.

"The World Trade has changed a lot of people, a lot of people are going through anxiety and stress," the guard said later, asking not to be identified. "Hopefully as I keep coming here I'll find serenity. I think this is the spot."

Pastors Dan and Anne Stratton and their daughter Danielle.

Many congregants are drawn to the reputed healing powers of Pastor Ann, who says that her prayers, along with the laying on of her hands, have vanquished cancers, returned sight to the blind, rid HIV carriers of the virus, and once revived a man who suffered a heart attack during a service. It is a gift she said she discovered at age 20, and many in the congregation insist that it is real. They stand in line to be healed.

"She's awesome," said Rosa Rivera, a nurse from Washington Heights who has been a congregation member since 1997. Like others, Rivera can be brought to her knees when Pastor Ann summons divine help. "You fall under the power of the Holy Spirit," she said. "You can't stand in the presence of God."


Unbeknown to the church's Tribeca neighbors, they too are remembered in prayer at Faith Exchange Fellowship.

Standing before his congregation, Pastor Dan asked that the church's presence in the neighborhood improve children's schoolwork, strengthen husbands and wives' relationships, boost families' finances, and even lead to greater accomplishments by the community board.

"We believe this is the healthiest and safest part of New York," Stratton said. "We're here now."