Commission Tells Park to Change Its Stripes

by Carl Glassman,

“I think I’m going bold,” said Roanne Kolvenbach, a Reade Street resident, as she looked over some color swatches.

During last month¹s vote, Patrick Mulligan and son Ben, 3, decide among.  Photo by Carl Glassman

“I’m going neutral,” said her friend Susanne Bober, from Church Street.

The two women with opposite tastes could well have been choosing the rug for a bedroom or the right shirt to go with a new pair of pants. Instead, they were voting on a color scheme for the Washington Market Park’s newly expanded playground. Its temporary blue-and-purple striped surface has enraged many who look down on the park from apartments across the street.

The balloting, conducted by Fraya Berg, Harriet Grimm and Karen Brodsky for the park’s board of directors, took place May 18 on the spongy, colorful surface that will soon be history. Thirty- seven ballots were cast, including several by voters young enough to have a proprietary interest in the outcome:

  • Beige and gray stripes/yellow circles—18
  • Beige and gray stripes/blue circles—10
  • Dark and light blue stripes/yellow circles—9

While there is no shortage of residents who find the fuss more than a little petty, the city’s Art Commission, which must approve visible changes to city property, had given the matter an official and very sober hearing in City Hall the previous week, leading to the community poll.

At the hearing, Lee Weintraub, the park’s landscape architect, made his pitch for keeping the blue and purple. Then he listened, grim-faced, to the

complaints of several neighbors who said the colors have spoiled their view.

“I miss looking out my window and seeing something that is smooth and natural, that goes with the green and the trees,” said Valerie Cates of 311 Greenwich St., who started a petition in November that got the Park Board and eventually the Art Commission to take note. (Cates argued for solids, but the commission said that they had previously approved stripes.)

Weintraub’s color choice was defended by the board’s president, Bill Watson, and its former president, Andy Freireich, who argued it was premature to judge the surface without seeing the surrounding plants and play equipment. “We’re in the middle of the project and I think we should look at it [the surface] when it’s done,” Watson said.

The commissioners were split over Weintraub’s stripes, but they voted unanimously to oppose blue and purple and to send the decision back to the community.

Weintraub’s second choice, beige-and-gray stripes with yellow circles, was a winner.

 

A child plays on the controversial  blue and purple play surface.  During last month¹s vote, Patrick Mulligan and son Ben, 3, decide among.  Photo by Carl Glassman