Victims' Families Protest 'Freedom Center' on WTC Site


By Barry Owens

The prospect of politics on display in a portion of the future memorial planned at the World Trade Center site has some relatives of the victims killed in the Sept. 11 attacks angry. Representatives from more than a dozen victims family groups rallied at the site on June 20 in opposition to the International Freedom Center, a planned 300,000 square foot museum dedicated to the concept of freedom with exhibits documenting the struggle for democracy and human rights not only America but world-wide.

Family members say there may be a place for that discussion, but not at the memorial.

"No one who has come to the World Trade Center in the past four years has asked about world politics. Why? Because it isn't the appropriate place. Everyone knows that," said Edie Lutnick, who lost a brother, Gary, in the attacks." You want world politics? Go to the U.N."

The family groups, who say their concerns are not being heard by the Lower Manhattan Development Corporation, are taking their fight to block the International Freedom Museum to the public by seeking signatures on a petition at their web site, www.takebackthememorial.com.

"The International Freedom Center will become a magnet for protest," said Charles Wolf, whose wife was killed in attacks and leads the Coalition of 9/11 Families. Wolf said his concern is that the museum would be an ideological-based organization and one that "does not belong as part of a memorial experience."

"I'm all for freedom of speech," he added, "but there is a right place and a wrong place. "This is the wrong place."

At a later news conference, John Cahill, appointed by Gov. George Pataki to lead the rebuilding effort, defended the Center and said it would not be allowed to become a place for "left wing or right wing politics."

"It's important what we have here is not a place for political polemics," he said "but a place to memorialize the history of man's march toward freedom and to remember the role that Sept. 11 plays in that important march."

At a rally on Church Street near the World Trade Center site, family members display photos of lost loved ones in protest over the planned International Freedom Center at the memorial. Photo: Stephanie Keith
John Whitehead, LMDC chairman, said the notion that the Center would be political in nature was a "misconception." But he did express concern that those notions and a vocal opposition to the museum could hamper private fund raising efforts for the memorial.

"People will be reluctant to give if they think there is confusion and chaos," he said.

The Center is part of the complex that will also house a cultural center. A ramp will lead from the building site to a memorial below ground near the bedrock, slurry wall and reflecting pools that will be the site of a memorial to the victims of the attacks.

At the rally, about 200 relatives of victims held up signs and chanted "take back the memorial" and "9/11 memorial only."

Tourists Michael and Teresa Jahn of Dixon, Illinois crowded in for a closer look.

"It should not be about politics," she said of the future museum. "It breaks our heart, and we don't even know the people who lost their lives here."