‘Gimme Shelter’ Say Bus-Riding Seniors

by Barry Owens

In Battery Park City along North End Avenue, black cars sit at the ready for their clients, and taxis head to West Street with passengers and a purpose.
At a bus stop outside 450 North End Avenue, Pearl Scher, in foreground, stands with fellow seniors who are being denied a shelter by the building’s management. Photo: Allan Tannenbaum

Then there’s the M22 bus.

It lumbers up the avenue every 20 minutes or so, snorts to a stop, and opens its doors to passengers who, depending on the weather, could be rain-soaked, wilted from the heat or shivering.

With no shelter at the bus stop, those passengers—often coming from the Hallmark seniors residence across the street—are at the mercy of the elements.

So when Pearl Scher, a Hallmark resident and member of Community Board 1, began lobbying a year ago for a shelter at the stop for “her people,” she thought it was an obvious and easy sell.


“It seemed to me such a reasonable request that there wasn’t any doubt in my mind it would be approved,” Scher said.

So far, she’s been proved wrong.

The location meets the Department of Transportation’s criteria for installing a shelter and the request is supported by the Battery Park City Authority and Community Board 1.

But the plan hasn’t earned the approval of the building management at Tribeca Bridge Towers, at 450 North End Avenue, which is next to the bus stop.

In a letter to the Department of Transportation, building manager George Limbach of Glenwood Management Corp. denied the agency’s request to install a shelter, without explanation, according to Scher.

“They don’t have to give an explanation and they didn’t,” she said.

Limbach did not return repeated calls for comment.

According to Department of Transportation regulations, business and property owners closest to the site of a proposed bus shelter or other sidewalk fixture have the right to deny the installation for any reason, said Kay Sarlin, a DOT spokeswoman. Unless the building managers have a change of heart, there will be no shelter in front of 450 North End Avenue, she added.

“We really want to help any member of the community that we can and we will look for other [nearby] areas that a bus shelter might be possible,” Sarlin said.

“It’s a big deal,” said Michelle Dewitt, activities director at the Hallmark, who often sees residents leaning on the building, sitting on their walkers or taking shelter in a nearby deli while they wait for the bus. “One of the reasons they moved down here is because they like the fact that there’s bus service uptown to Lincoln Center and up that way.”

Resident Henry Suss said the lack of a shelter was a hardship for residents, particularly those with handicaps.

“They try hard to go places, like anyone else,” said Suss. “And they’re not going to go on the subway. That’s 45 steps down.”

Scher insists she will continue to fight for a shelter, even a temporary one.

“Listen, if the city puts in a temporary shelter, that means it will be there for 50 years,” she said.

At least one Hallmark resident and frequent bus rider, who did not want to be identified, said she was not holding her breath.

“Why should they care?” she asked, shrugging. “A lot of people down here can afford to take a taxi. Look, there goes another one.”