Ferry
Fumes Mar Park Summer. But for What?
by Carl Glassman
Back in early June, Battery Park City parents filled the meeting room
of Community Board 1 to vent their anger.
The NY Waterway ferry terminal near the Mercantile Exchange was about
to close, making way for the construction of a new, enlarged terminal
nearby. In the meantime, a temporary terminal would open across from the
Rockefeller Park playground, bringing commuter ferries and the clouds
of diesel exhaust that accompany them.
They chose the worst spot they could, said Magdelena Hasiec,
the mother of two small daughters, who had gathered more than 200 signatures
on a petition to protest the siting of the terminal. The children
at the playground will come in direct contact with the fumes.
In a voice full of contrition, George Cancro, the Port Authoritys
director of ferry operations, told the parents that this was the only
available site for the temporary terminal while work is done on the new
five-slip facility at the World Financial Center, due for completion in
2005.
We know this isnt the most desirable location for the temporary
terminal, Cancro told them. We want to get it out of there
as quickly as possible.
Perhaps. But as the ferries puffed away through the summer and cautious
parents avoided the park when the wind blew eastor stayed away altogetherno
work at the new terminal site had begun. That left some parents wondering:
what was the rush to put a terminal near the playground in the first place?
They could have left the terminal where it was and moved it when
it was necessary, complained Herbert Bauernebel, the father of 16-month-old
Maxwell. But we still go there, depending on the direction of the
wind.
Port Authority spokesman Steve Coleman said the old terminal, near the
Mercantile Exchange, couldnt remain in use because it was in disrepair,
and it didnt pay to fix it if were going to put a new
facility in real soon afterwards.
In July, Coleman said that work on the retaining wall, in preparation
for the permanent terminal, was to begin shortly. (The terminal
itself is being constructed off-site.) But late last month, he amended
that start date to by the end of the year.
Outrageous! exclaimed Monika Dralle, when told by a reporter
that work on the ferry site was still months away. Dralle, who used to
enjoy taking her daughter to the park, characterized as convenient
the Port Authoritys talk of disrepair as a reason for opening the
temporary terminal so soon.
That wasnt in the discussion at all, she said of the
June community board meeting with Port Authority officials. She said she
left that meeting feeling assured that work on the new site needed to
begin immediately.
I thought, Oh great, theyre going to start working right
away. Then were waiting, waiting and we just noticed theres
not one thing being done. Not a thing.
The Battery Park City Authority responded to parents fears about
air quality by asking the Port Authority to monitor ferry emissions. Coleman
said that study would begin this month, but it is not clear what steps
would be taken if the results are unsatisfactory. No matter what, many
parents dont want their children exposed to the dark exhaust; meanwhile,
NY Waterway says it already is working as fast as it can to put its cleanest
boats on the route.
BPC Authority president Tim Carey, who ordered the tests, wouldnt
speculate. I dont deal in what-ifs, he said.
|