Tribeca Trib

Manhattan Real Estate

 
Tribeca Trib
Search
  Print page

Fishmarket Recalled In Seaport Show

By Andrea Appleton
POSTED MAY 2, 2008


At the April 26 opening of the South Street Seaport Museum’s new exhibit, “The Photographs of Barbara Mensch,” gallery goers sipped white wine and strolled past atmospheric black and white photographs of the Fulton Fish Market as it was in the late 1970s and early 1980s. In a speech to the assembled, the curator spoke of Mensch’s photos as “a guide to the city as a palimpsest, where there are layers of invisible history.”

But to Bobby DiGregorio, Mensch’s photographs weren’t abstract art works requiring fancy speeches.

“See that guy? That’s Albino,” he said, pointing to a gripping portrait of a man in a rubber apron staring at the camera with a fish in each hand. “The thing I remember most about him is when this other guy hit him over the head with a shovel, his head went ‘Bing!’” He paused as one of the oral histories
Mensch gathered a quarter century ago played on a nearby speaker. “That’s Johnny Lollygag. He was called that because he was always lollygagging around.”

A photo of DiGregorio himself—or “Bobby Reliable,” as he was known on South Street—hung nearby. In the picture he is filleting a shad, one of a number of jobs he held at the market, where he worked for 33 years. “It was a special place,” he said. “The saloons and the boats, the men and the fights and the fish. It was great!” He now works at the market’s new location in the Bronx, where it moved in 2005. “I might as well be selling shoes,” he said. “It’s like a Home Depot or something.”

It was to preserve something of the world that DiGregorio describes that Barbara Mensch first ventured into the fish market in 1979. It was a tense time, with the market under investigation for mob control and the pressures of gentrification beginning to encroach. No one was inclined to be friendly to a woman with a camera.


“It took an incredible amount of patience,” Mensch said. “The first time I walked into the Paris Bar [which still exists], I got thrown out on my butt!” But for four years, Mensch kept coming back. Last year she published “South Street,” a beautiful visual and written history of the time she spent getting to know the market’s denizens. 

“In hindsight,” she told the crowd, “the story of South Street wasn’t really about fish.” Mensch spoke of loyalty, respect, the sense of depth of character and conviction that she saw in the people she came to know there. “If you fast forward to the world we live in now, I don’t think we see that richness,” she said.

DiGregorio, for his part, has nothing but respect for Mensch. “Thank God for Barbara,” he said. “If she didn’t take these photographs, there would just be a couple of us old-timers with our memories.”

Barbara Mensch’s photos are on display through December. For information on the show and programs this month, go to southstreetseaportmuseum.org or call 212-748-8600.

 

[Home][Back][Archives] [Advertise][Contact]
The Tribeca Trib · 401 Broadway, 5th Floor · New York, NY · 10013 · 212.219.9709